Enda Kenny The Teaching Pension Question? 20th Feb 2011
UPDATED: 21st Feb 2011
Details
about Enda Kenny has emerged surrounding his 30 year teaching pension of €100,000 for which he
only actually worked for four years to get. Further details are HERE. Said TD Billy Kelleher: "Having refused
to answer questions about his teaching pension for over a week he has now admitted that he deliberately deferred it in order
to get a bigger payout. It now appears that he will get paid 3 pensions – TD, minister and teacher and that he will
get the teaching pension for 34 years service even though he didn’t set foot in a classroom for 30 of those years.”
Enda has responded though by stating "Just in case anybody has any misunderstanding about this, because
my situation was as a former teacher in that profession and simply because I paid into a pension fund. In case anybody has
any illusions that the leader of the Fine Gael party is anyway involved in a money situation here, I will not be accepting
any pension from the teaching profession". While this to date might be true, there is questions by some over if
he is just waiting to claim the money when reaching a time seemed appropriate later. Claiming sometime in
the future, a thirty year pension later for actually only working four years as a teacher, has been questioned
by others. Is it seen possibly as another elected representitive continuing a Dail TD tradition of cleverly
putting money away or just deferring it for another quiet day, some have pondered and ask!
Update: Although Mr Kenny has quickly opted to relinquish the pension, such was the fast rising possible
scandal, similar people with same conditions, have not. Fianna Fail minister Pat Carey" stated he'd taken €120,000
pension lump sum pay-off in recent years from 30 years' teaching even though he handn't been teaching for any
of those 30 years. "Yes I am entitled to a pension and I will draw it," he said. Fianna
Fail deputy leader Mary Hanafin said she had an €11,500-a-year pension pot built up from teaching once she retires, which
she would also be claiming for her non-practising teachers position. Further details here.
Comment Tuesday's
8th Feb' TV3 Debate
The debate
on the 8th was a bit of a let down by both sides over all - I expected more and definitely better! However
more so, the constant rude arrogance, the consistent interruptions and talking over by Mr Martin was a right turn off. Who
taught this supposed professional good manners? At least Mr Gilmore behaved with more decorum and in professional manner!
…As for this constant stance of his “I don’t accept your view etc…” –
of course you don’t Mr Martin, your a member of an organisation that has consistent members that has robbed
from the people, from the state departments direct and from our very bank accounts, of course you don’t accept anything
else anyone has to say – its typical denial of what ye and the rest of your Mafia style political party has done to
the state and the way ye treat us all in open spite towards us! Your manners last night were typical of Fianna Fail –
supposedly better than the rest of us and talking down to us rather than conversing across to us. You might have the PR practised
words down to a tee – but your actions with the rest of your mob for many, many years betray your actual mode of operation
and attitude – and look where it has got to the state and people! …Only the blind sheep of the country are
still in denial about you and Fianna Fail!
You
and you party Mr Martin are a disgrace and like it or not, supporters like it or not, this is part of the reason why ye all
will get the boot from government offices on election day. Good riddance to bad rubbish!
Enda Kenny by the
way should have no say on last nights debate except as a private citizen. He couldn't even bother his backside to turn
up – just giving one miserable excuse after another for his absence. Shame on him.
Admin.
Will He Or Won't he Turn up?
It Sure Don't Look Good!
COMMENT - 8th Feb' 2011 Fine Gael Enda Kenny Still An Empty Chair?
Enda Kenny so far with three now excuses being used, as of one o'clock, deny TV3 and the
Irish population, the chance to see him answer some very important questions tonight on a televised national debate. There
will be an empty chair/podium where he is supposed to be positioned. The general concenus amid a lot of the Irish
people appears to be that he is running scared, using one excuse after another to avoid the debate. If he will change his
mind at the last minute, we will have to tune in tonight to find out.
Meanwhile there is the thought that if
Enda can't face two fellow Irish others - how can the Irish people have any credability in him facing European and world
leaders, not including corportate tax bullies such as Sarkosy and co? It doesn't inspire confidence! It appears
he would rather face a smaller group of people with little or no questioning, than face the nation to equal questioning -
but still he begs for our vote! Admin is not impressed - not impressed at all! He's supposed to be a future country
leader (and behave like one) - yet he won't even allow himself to be examined on his policies before the national people!
He is helping to continue the farce that is Irish politics - not solving the farce! So much for transparancy and clarity
from those that want us to vote for them! Its the same disgusting behaviour as before by many TD's.
This election is supposed to be about change. Change from the old ways of doing things. Admin can see none in the future coming
by this indicative empty chair and missing person!
Admin is very disappointed.
Admin' Special Comment Bertie Ahern
Quiting Politics
31/12/2010
It has been announced by Mr Ahern that he is retiring from politics. Sadly it twenty years too late at least.
This questionable character should have been gone a long time ago! His list of suspicious activities, many dodgy statements
and other activities that have been mentioned inside and outside the Dail, have given many a reason for him to be more investigated
and subsequently have his backside slapped behind bars. A place the Admin of this site believes he should be!
With the gall of the man, he still says he might even still run for president of Ireland. Maybe he is taking the piss
(whats new, he's done it for most of his political life its opinionated) and maybe he's serious (in that case he still
needs his head examined) but one thing is for sure, he certainly is no saint and does NOT deserve to hold any office, never
mind a presidential one.
There should have been better, deeper investigations into this man and all
those involved with him. Will that happen? Are you for real! Welcome to Ireland and the way things are done here via Fianna
Fail. What Bertie and co did, its deeply suspected that many on the opposition benches have equally participated
in or done similar - along with our corrupt government party! So the last thing you will see is anyone of serious blame, name
or offshoot, go to jail.
ALL DON'T WANT THE SKELETONS COMING OUT
OF THE CLOSETS!
Those that could talk and spill the beans, either died in a strange
Russia car accident, was paid off with pensions and perks (including a car!) and let go quietly into the night, well off.
Jeasus, O'Donaghue was/still is allowed to hang on to his Dail seat for fcuks sake - and still the perks/pensions
that come with it! As for further investigations, any that tried to take place, their terms of reference
(investigation areas) was strictly curtailed till any investigation body was allowed to investigate bugger all. They were
not allowed to follow down certain trails! Money trails, people and their questionable action trails... etc. Why?
Well its the opinion of many that the government and opposition doesn't want the digging deeper into certain
matters for it would expose just how bad the REAL corruption is within our political parties and how high
up it goes (and even down to local council level)! What Bertie should be accountable for is a lot - but in reality we
can only suspect, is the tip of the iceberg.
As we have seen in England, when such corruption has been
exposed - at least some have been held accountable. As in one case, one MP fudged his meals expenses and got prison!
What have we done here - and much worse has been fudged? (Just look at O'Donague's antics for example!) ...NOTHING.
...Well thats a bit of a lie, we have actually given the culprits MASSIVE pensions, MASSIVE leaving payoff's,
even allowed comfortable political seat keeping for others, and many more advantageous (well at least to them!) bonuses. Besides
coming up with "In negotiation" tax clearance cert's in order to let Bertie remain in the Dail - even if he
still has not made clear he's paid off just some of the taxes he still owes the state! (And we will
STILL be paying him €300,000+ in leaving money and pensions of at least €35,000 to €50,000 a month!)
Welcome to the state of Irish politics as it stands today. Utterly corrupt and still
lead by probably the most evil, corrupt white collar party in Ireland (How the scumbag Greens are still propping it up
is another moral question altogether. It says a lot about them individually too!)
Bertie Ahern should have been
gone a long time ago but should maybe still be considered as a candidate for a position behind bars!
We can only
live in hope!
*** SPECIAL COMMENT ***.
Fianna Fails Last Laugh At The Publics Expense! 18th January 2010
Yet again we are it appears going to be treated to a state farce. The joke that will be called the
"Irish Banks Inquiry" is going to be undermined, controlled and it scope conveniently limited from the very start.
Fianna Fail (in my opinion) is attempting (and more than likely succeed with) a whitewash of what happened. It been stated
this morning that Brian Cowen will be in public avoiding questions over his supervision of the banking sector as
Finance Minister while the whole farce was going on. A man that was DIRECTLY at the heart of the matter will not be
questioned - how crazy an inquiry from the get-go can you get!
To make matters worse, FF want the
damn thing held in secret - behind closed doors! To many, this comes as no surprise - as its already been shown that many
members of FF have their dirty hands buried in the whole mess and are up to their necks involved. RTE's "Primetime"
a number of weeks ago showed this alone. Some of those from Fianna Fail involved include Councillor Sean McCarthy, Senator
Francie O'Brien, Senator Don Lydon, Charlie McCreevy and even Bertie Ahern's then other half! Follow-up
example newspaper storyHERE
Fianna Fail before they get their asses kicked in the next election, are having
one final big laugh and once again treating the public with the same disregarding contempt that they now are renowned for.
Its a state organised cover-up - and we deserve it, for we are letting them get away with it. Those that sit
around the top table of FF know broadly who is involved. What have they come up with? Probably an inquiry that will limit
the range of areas that can be looked into, who can be looked into and areas that are off limits. Convenient eh? Cowen to escape grilling - story: HERE Example report of secret inquiry - story:HERE and HERE
P.S. Don't forget, YOU as a tax payer will be paying for this waste
of an inquiry. It will be your tax money that is going to be uselessly thrown away. Two of the involved bankers have already
or this in this week, doing a runner to countries that have little or no extradition treaties! (one has moved to Marbella
and another one has moved to Africa!) Flight of the developers - story HERE
Welcome to the Irish way of doing things - or should I say Fianna Fails way of doing
things? The opposition should stand up in the Dail and publicly state for for the record that "after
the next election if the current oncoming inquiry and its FULL scope is not held in public and ALL those involved not brought
to account under a totally independent inquiry, the current opposition will pick up where a previous inquiry stopped or failed
to go". Anything less is aiding and abetting a cover-up.
Further
more, history will be our judge yet again and some of us will be found guilty of incompetence, failure to do our full duty
and guilty of lack of action.
Admin. Unitedpeople.ie
Miep Gieps RIP A Simple Tribute To A Brave Lady. 13th
January 2010
Unitedpeople would like to pay tribute to Miep Gieps who this week passed away. She was a quiet brave lady who tried
to save the life of Anne Frank and her family. Her passing is sad but the lessons she taught the world with the quiet bravery
of her actions should never be forgotten.
Ms Gies died from a neck injury sustained in a fall at her home shortly
before Christmas, Anne Frank Museum spokeswoman Annemarie Bekker said. Ms Gies was the last of the few non-Jews who supplied
food, books and good cheer to the secret annex behind the canal warehouse where Anne, her parents, sister and four other Jews
hid for 25 months during World War Two. After the apartment was raided by the German police, Ms Gies gathered up Anne's
scattered notebooks and papers and locked them in a drawer for her return after the war. The diary, which Anne was given
on her 13th birthday, chronicles her life in hiding from June 12, 1942, until August 1, 1944. Anne died of typhus at age 15
in the Bergen-Belsen concentration camp in March 1945, just two weeks before the camp was liberated. Ms Gies gave the diary
to Anne's father, Otto, the only survivor, who then published it in 1947.
After the diary was published,
Ms Gies tirelessly promoted causes of tolerance. She brushed aside the accolades for helping hide the Frank family as more
than she deserved -- as if, she said, she had tried to save all the Jews of occupied Holland. "This is very unfair. So
many others have done the same or even far more dangerous work," she was quoted as saying just days before her 100th
birthday last February.
For her courage, Ms Gies was bestowed with the 'Righteous Gentile' title by
the Israeli Holocaust museum Yad Vashem. She was also honoured by the German government, Dutch monarchy and educational
institutions. 'The Diary of Anne Frank' was the first popular book about the Holocaust, and has been read by millions
of children and adults around the world in 70 languages.
Iran Stamps Down On Memorials For Cleric Sat Dec' 26th 2009
In an effort to stamp out any vocal opposition of any kind at any place,
Irans dictatorship leaders have banned memorial gatherings for a leading dissident cleric, with the exception of those in
his birthplace and the holy city of Qom. News of clashes from Isfahan has managed to reach the outside world despite once
again Iran attemps to stifle any news getting out.
UPDATE: As the people's struggle for basic rights take
place, the Iranian government is trying hard to close down more forms of communication and posting of news which shows
discrepencies in what they are saying on their official media stations. The Iran government has blocked BBC broadcasts, banned
world reporters, cut further internet access to the rest of the world including "Youtube", as well as cutting
mobile communication in cities and troublesome spots. However news is still leaking out of the government actions
and their treatment of their own people. An example of this is the following news clip which shows a protester being
run over by a state police car on the 27th of December. .
WATCH CLIP BELOW AT OWN DISCRETION (Further clips found HERE)
Al-Qaeda Tortured Secretly in Lithuania 26th Dec' 2009
Unnamed sources
leaked that a secret CIA prison was built in 2004 which was used for over a year to torture a minimum of eight Afghani terrorists.
The prison could be accessed from underground. Originally it had no windows, according to the locals. The two story prison
is now a training facility for the Lithuanian security service. Public officials continue to deny that such a prison has ever
existed, but Lithuanian President Grybauskaite insists that a proper investigation be made into the allegations
Uganda Outlaws Female Circumcision 21 Dec' 2009
The African country of Uganda has outlawed female genital mutilation after parliament unanimously voted in
favour of the legislation. The bill gives anyone who performs the procedure 10 years in prison. Anyone who uses force to make
a woman undergo the procedure faces a sentence of life in prison. Uganda's shadow health minister said: "This
operation is so painful, so cruel, and these so-called surgeons are paid to do it." He added that while he's on the
opposition party, "I supported the bill with all my strength and heart." According to the United Nations,
100-140 million women worldwide have been victims of the procedure.
New American Waiting Airline Changes 22nd Dec' 2009
The Obama
administration is ordering airlines to change company policies, now forcing them to allow passengers who have been waiting
for three hours on the ground due to delays to depart their planes. Consumer advocates call it a "Christmas miracle."
The industry says the stricter rules Obama is imposing will result in even
more more canceled flights and inconvenience for passengers. But Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood said having to sit on
a plane for 5-7 hours without explanation is worse.The government claims
that about 114,000 passengers per year are delayed more than three hours while on an airplane. In August, Mesaba Airlines
kept 47 passengers on a plane overnight, for which it was slapped with an unprecedented government fine.
Iran Attack Sould Be used As Last Resort 21 Dec' 2009
U.S. military
officer Mike Mullen is getting more apprehensive as the deadline on Iran's nuclear face-off draws ever nearer. Iran was
given an approximate time to relate their decisions, the final time being set for the end of this year. His main concern is Iran’s lack of response, saying that "the clock [is] now running"
on the amount of time that Obama will keep up his concerted effort toward a compromise of some sort with Iran. Even though Iran still claims the stations in question are to produce electrical energy
for household consumers and the public sector, many doubt their intent. Mullen said that any military attack on Iran through
Israel or the U.S. should be a last option
Star Trek - Illegally Downloaded Most 27th Dec' 2009
According
to TorrentFreak a blog site, the most illegally downloaded film this year was Star Trek at an estimate of around 10 Million
times by internet users. Amid the rest of the other top films downloaded was Transformers, 2012 and Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs.
TorrentFreak also noted that what the box office stated as the most popular were not necessarily mirrored in results on the
site. All the data was collected from the largest of the BitTorrent trackers.
Ryanair
Gets Told Off - Again! 04 Jan 2009
Britians Office of Fair Trading (OFT) today has given out yet again over
Ryanair and its method of charging. They hit out at the company charging people for paying by card, the only method
Ryanair allows, and for that basic ability they slap on an additional fee that you can't escape from. Your charged
for paying for your previous charges!
There was a "free" Electron card option at one stage
but when people started to go to the bother of taking that route, Ryanair quickly scrapped that method and replaced it
with a "MasterCard Pre-pay" option. The automatic insertion of insurance to flights was another area brought up
and legality questioned.
While the British OFT is currently reviewing the situation and laws, the
Irish government again is currently doing nothing still to clear-up and define the present laws and legality of charge fees
that can be applied. While they do nothing, it's a situation Ryanair is only too happy to see exist and possibly
use to their best monetary advantage.
American Victim Group Makes Request To Brian Cowen For Revealing Movement Details 29th
Dec' 2009
An American victim group that has been chronicling the current
US clergy sexual abuse scandal has released the namesof 60 to 70 accused priests it says were born in Ireland
or are of Irish descent who came to the United States and were re-offenders. The group who's website www.bishopaccountability.org has listed upon their site a well documented database of 3,000 names of accused priests and roughly a third are linked
to Ireland, which is reeling from revelations of a decades-long coverup of abuse in the Dublin Archdiocese. They called on Brian
Cowen to recognize his country’s responsibility to inform the American public of all child-molesting clergy from
Irish dioceses and religious orders who have immigrated to US dioceses. The Roman Catholic Church which has been found previously
to me moving many, many of their brotherhood around the world to avoid questioning and possible charges have come under further
pressure for more honesty and transparency.
The
request comes as the Church in Ireland is currently resisting the calls for further investigation of the remaining diocese's within Ireland, Mr Cowen and Fianna Fail has allowed itself to be
seen as they too not wanting any further checking, for the matter go quietly away undocumented. Irish victim groups has repeatedly
called for further investigations for the rest of the country despite the stalling possibly going on.
At a press release conference yesterday, Helen L. McGonigle, a Connecticut lawyer, held
up a a picture of herself at age 6. McGonigle said she was 6 when she was abused by a priest named Brendan Smyth, who left
a trail of abuse in Britain and Ireland before he came to work in East Greenwich, R.I. Smyth died in an Irish prison in 1997, shortly after pleading guilty to 74 counts of sexually abusing 20 Irish boys
and girls between 1958-1993. “We know it was problem in the Diocese
of Providence having this Irish priest who was a known pedophile,’’ said McGonigle, now 48. “This is a classic example of an organization that doesn’t give a hoot about protecting
children,’’ she said.
Jeffrey
Thomas stated that he also had been abused by Smyth. Thomas filed suit in Providence Superior Court against the Diocese
of Providence and others, alleging that he had been abused by Smyth at an East Greenwich, R.I., parish school.
“I am a survivor of clergy abuse,’’
he said outside the Cathedral of the Holy Cross. “The bigger crime to me is that [Smyth’s] superiors knew about
his appetite and his sexual desires and still put him in populations with small children to re-offend.’’ Also
named on the website list are the Rev. Joseph Maguire, who served in Waltham and died in prison in 2005 while serving a 44-year
sentence for abusing three boys.
Apple Stops Freedom Of Speech? 15th July 2010
Apple, of course, became a household name with its infamous 1984 commercial, about how Apple equipment would make
sure that "1984" wasn't like 1984. However, now that it's 2010, apparently it's fine!
As you may have heard, Consumer Reports posted that it could not recommend the iPhone 4 due to the widely discussed antenna
problems. This appears not to go down too well with Apple - and lets be honest, understandably so. However, if anyone tries
to even mention the report on their forum by name or try allude to it, messages are deleted, deleted, deleted and removed
from view immediately.
It seems at least one Apple forum has gone the way of Big Brother despite their
earlier advertising saying different! Further details HERE - a site where Apple is NOT able to shut the public up or delete their words!
Update: After
much quick publicity at the vanishing messages from the public (and they protesting at their words being removed), a
few messages now have suddenly re-appeared! Its been commented on many a web blog that publicity exposing the previous behaviour
on Apple's forum has created maybe this sudden reversal of vanishing message posts!
British Royals Upseting The Public Again! 27th Dec'2009
In a effort to gain back some privacy, the British royal family has instead upset a lot of their public.
The latest example was withnessed at a mass the royals attended in Norfork, England over Christmas. It now appears that a
British senior police over stepped his legal boundries and demanded that the watching public hand over all their cameras,
confiscating them. This was done following a request from the royals that they get less cameras pointed at them in future!
Tables were even set-up for the collection of public cameras giving the notion that this questionable legal move was well
planned in advance of the Royals attending mass there. The reaction from the pubic on the day was anger and outrage. The same
reaction is being felt by a lot of Englands public in general as news filtered through the media to the rest of
the nation.
This latest abuse of police powers comes as the Royals demand that they have a right to tighter
privacy. The British queen days earlier moaned to the English media that she was unhappy with the present situation and demanded
that the media photographers back off. For many, this is seen as a highhandness contradiction as the royals ask at other
times that certain events and their people, be captured on film when and if its only convenient to them. An arrogance
and disregard its been seen as, for the people that is putting money into their royal pockets and bank accounts.
First up: "Borderlands" from Gearbox The game that installing for a PC can be hell
just to do!
How
The Single Transferable Voting System Works. The Journal.ie Explains: Click Here
Rome Yet Again Refuses To Budge 15th
July 2010
The Vatican is issued the lates updats
to their rules governing how to deal with childabuse found in the organisation by member priests. The rules included fast
tracking investigations of anyone found to behaving in such a bad way. What has not changed however is that such crimes are
to be reported to the a proper state legal authorty. Many governments, victim organisations and victions themselves have called
for years now for such crimes to be compulsary reported and handed over to the civil courts. The pope and the Vatican instead
however yet again, has decided to completely ignore that issue yet again.
"Clergy sex crimes must
be reported to police and the Vatican must make this a binding policy that is uniformly enforced," said David Clohessy,
of The Survivors Network for those Abused by Priests. "Today's action doesn't do that.
In a further testiment to show how completely the pope and Catholic organisation is out of touch with values of decency, they
have listed the existance of female priests as par in evil with child abuse and murder. News of this latest out of date action
is forcing many 70 plus high level clergy members into leaving the Rome organisation and setting up their own religious catholic
system. Apparently an enlargening of an already widening split is on the cards as Rome grows more and more out of touch
daily it seems.
Earth's north magnetic pole is moving
fairly rapidly -- nearly 40 miles a year -- in the direction of Russia, according to new research, and data points to a region
of rapidly shifting magnetic activity on the surface of the Earth's core. That
in turn may be caused by a strange magnetic "plume" originating from deeper inside the core, scientists say. The
magnetic north pole is being dragged by these changes from its long-time home in northern Canada. Magnetic north is the place compass needles actually point to, and is near the geographic North
Pole but not quite in the same spot. Though GPS has largely replaced magnetic compasses for navigation, many people still
find them useful.
Happy 18th Birthday - Your Present? We are going to stone you to death! 15th July
2010
Imagine a girl forced into a marriage at 14. A year later
she is found guilty of "adultery" without any evidence. They could not execute her as she was a minor so they
gave her 99 lashes and then dumped her in a cell until she is 18. When she turns 18 (soon), she gets stoned to death.
Teenager Mina Ahadi became that person and victim of Irans twisted religious out of date rules.
Chinese Disedent gets 11 Years
For Asking For Reforms! Sat Dec' 26th 2009
The longest charges ever handed down by a chinese court against someone asking for reorms, has been handed
out. The sentencing of Liu Xiaobo, took place after he called for political reforms and an end to Communist Party dominance.
The outcry at the harsh sentence which drew diplomatic criticism, came from many European countries and with the United
States saying it went against international norms.
The vague charge of 'inciting to subvert state power'
is routinely used to jail dissidents. Liu could have been sentenced for up to 15 years in prison under the charge. The state-run
Xinhua news agency only reported the news in English -- a sign the government does not want its people to know about Liu's
case. Instead, the top Xinhua headline in Chinese declared 2009 a year of "citizens' rights."
"We are deeply concerned by the sentence of 11 years in prison," said Gregory
May, first secretary with the US Embassy. May was one of a dozen diplomats stopped by authorities from attending the trial
and sentencing. "Persecution of individuals for the peaceful expression of political views is inconsistent with internationally
recognised norms of human rights," May said. UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Navi Pillay, called it a sentence
that was a setback for Chinese activists.
"Cases such as that
of Liu Xiaobo risk not just halting, but seriously reversing that momentum" toward increasing democratic freedoms in
China, she said.
Nobel Prize Winner In Chinese Prison. Family
And Friends Bullied Into Silence.
Imprisoned in China and with close family members forbidden to leave the country, the Chinese dissident
Liu Xiaobo was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize on Friday, an empty chair representing his absence at the prize ceremony here.
For the first time in 75 years, no representative of the winner was allowed to make the trip to receive the
peace medal, a diploma and the $1.5 million check that comes with it. The last time that happened was in 1935, when Hitler
prevented that year’s winner, Count Carl von Ossietzky, who was imprisoned in a concentration camp, and indeed anyone
from Germany, from attending the ceremony. Noting Mr. Liu’s absence, the chairman of the Norwegian Nobel Committee,
Thorbjorn Jagland, said to a standing ovation: “This fact alone shows that the award was necessary and appropriate.”
“It is no coincidence that nearly all the richest countries in the world are democratic, because democracy mobilizes
new human and technological resources,” he said. “China’s new status entails increased responsibility. China
must be prepared for criticism, and regard it as a positive, as an opportunity for improvement.”
Representatives
from the 60-plus diplomatic missions accredited in Oslo normally attend the ceremony. But this year, 16 ambassadors, including
those from China and Russia, declined to attend, Nobel officials said, although not all characterized their absence as a direct
result of the intense pressure and threats of reprisal from China.
With no one to accept the Nobel medal
and diploma, they were ceremoniously placed on Mr. Liu’s empty chair.
The Norwegian actress and movie director
Liv Ullmann read a copy of Mr. Liu’s appeal to a Chinese court in December 2009, days before he was sentenced to 11
years in prison. “I have no enemies and no hatred,” Ms. Ullmann read. “Hatred can rot away at a person’s
intelligence and conscience. Enemy mentality will poison the spirit of a nation, incite cruel mortal struggles, destroy a
society’s tolerance and humanity, and hinder a nation’s progress toward freedom and democracy. That is why I hope
to be able to transcend my personal experiences as I look upon our nation’s development and social change, to counter
the regime’s hostility with utmost goodwill, and to dispel hatred with love.”
President Obama, who
won the peace prize last year, issued a statement saying Mr. Liu was “far more deserving of this award than I was,”
and calling for his release “as soon as possible.”
“We respect China’s extraordinary accomplishment
in lifting millions out of poverty, and believe that human rights include the dignity that comes with freedom from want,”
the president’s statement said. “But Mr. Liu reminds us that human dignity also depends upon the advance of democracy,
open society, and the rule of law.”
In Beijing, the Chinese authorities continued to pour vitriol on the award
while intensifying their crackdown on scores of people they perceive as a threat.
The Norwegian Nobel Committee has
said repeatedly that it did not intend to snub or attack China when it selected Mr. Liu, who has been a thorn in the government’s
side for years but is better known outside the country than inside. Instead, the committee said, the point is to remind China
that with power comes responsibility, and that economic growth should be coupled with political reform.
“The
fate of China will be the fate of the world,” Mr. Jagland said on Thursday. “If China is able to develop a social
market economy with full civil rights, it will have a positive impact on the world as a whole.”
Norway itself
has been punished by China, which recently called the five members of the Nobel committee “clowns.” Among other
things, China has indefinitely suspended bilateral trade talks between the two countries. The two countries have not spoken
officially since Mr. Liu was announced as the winner of the prize in October.
Mr. Liu was detained in December 2008,
after co-authoring Charter ‘08 — a call for reform and rights in China. In Beijing on Thursday, Zhang
Zuhua, a former official who helped write Charter ‘08, was forced into a vehicle by police officers, according to rights
advocates, and dozens of other people were either confined to their homes or escorted out of the capital. At least one of
them, the rights lawyer Teng Biao, was told by the police that he could return home on Sunday.
Blue construction
panels went up in front of Mr. Liu’s apartment building in an apparent attempt to block the sightlines of foreign cameramen
who gathered there throughout the day. Mr. Liu’s wife has been incommunicado inside her apartment since shortly after
the award was announced two months ago and other members of Mr. Liu’s family have been under tight surveillance.
Her
mother and one of his brothers were reluctant to speak to a reporter on Friday. In a text message, the brother, Liu Xiaoxuan,
apologized, saying his phone was being monitored.
Calls to many of the 140 people in China whom Ms. Liu had invited
to the ceremony yielded recordings saying their phones had been turned off. One of the few to pick up, Yu Fangqiang, the managing
partner of an AIDS organization, said he could not talk because a minder was sitting at his side.
Wang Songlian, a
researcher at Chinese Human Rights Defenders, said the tightened surveillance imposed on more than 300 people throughout the
country rivaled the restrictions imposed during the 2008 Beijing Olympics and the 60th anniversary of the Communist Party’s
ascension to power, which was celebrated last year.
Although the authorities have effectively silenced many of the
country’s most prominent critics, Ms. Wang said such efforts were self-defeating. “China has tried so hard to
show it can rise peacefully, but making people disappear doesn’t present a very good image to the outside world,”
she said. “It just shows how fearful the government is of dissent.”
On Friday, Global Times, a nationalistic,
populist tabloid affiliated with the party-owned People’s Daily, branded the ceremony a “political farce”
and described Oslo as a “cult center.” Even as the state media railed against the award, censors meticulously
scrubbed the Internet of any news stories or public comments that could be construed as sympathetic to Mr. Liu or the Nobel
Prize. Broadcasts by news outlets like CNN and the BBC were blacked out, and their Web sites were inaccessible to those unwilling
or unable to surmount the so-called Great Firewall. By most accounts, propaganda officials had done their job well.
In interviews with more than three dozen people across the capital on Friday, only a handful said they knew anything about
Mr. Liu. Most of those who had heard that a Chinese citizen was the recipient of the peace prize parroted the government’s
contention that the award was a Western plot to embarrass the country.
Even if she knew nothing about this year’s
honoree, Xiao Feng, a 27-year-old food industry worker whose long red scarf matched her smartly designed glasses, said she
thought he had probably done something to hinder China’s development. “I think this year’s prize is a little
bit unfair,” she said. “From what I can tell, its purpose is to humiliate China.”
Nobel officials
said on Friday that 48 countries had accepted the invitation while 16 ambassadors had declined.
The 16 absent envoys
were from China, Russia, Kazakhstan, Tunisia, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Iraq , Iran, Vietnam, Afghanistan, Venezuela, Egypt,
Sudan, Cuba, the Palestinian Authority and Morocco, the officials said.
News reports earlier put the number of stayaways
at 19 or 20. About 100 Chinese dissidents attended.
The list of countries not attending includes Western allies, like
Egypt and Saudi Arabia, which, irrespective of their international ties, resemble countries like China where power is centralized
and dissent is not tolerated. The countries attending include the United States, many European nations and emerging economies
like India and South Africa.
It was not the first time a prominent dissident had been awarded the prize: Andrei D.
Sakharov, the Soviet physicist, the Polish labor leader Lech Walesa and the Burmese pro-democracy campaigner Daw Aung San
Suu Kyi, have all been named winners and were represented at the Oslo ceremony by close relatives. A group of Nobel
laureates offered on Friday to mediate with the Chinese government in an effort to hasten Mr. Liu’s release. The laureates,
including the former South African President F. W. de Klerk, the Iranian human rights lawyer Shirin Ebadi and the writer
Elie Wiesel, signed a statement addressed to China’s government, requesting the opportunity to “discuss the status
of Liu Xiaobo and to establish what steps might be taken to facilitate his early release.”